Repairing a Pop Up Sink Drain

We just got back from a short trip to Vienna, Virginia to visit my family for the holidays. When we arrived, my mom had left me a note in the bathroom we were using.

Here it is:

My mom, she’s so cute, doesn’t she know that this sign taunted me the whole visit?

Besides, what kind of daughter would I be if I left this minor repair to a plumber? Puh-lease!

So, here was the deal with the hair clip in the sink. It was her way of holding the stopper up because the rod inside the sink had rusted and broken off. (Pretty creative in my opinion.)

But not the real fix for a sink stopper that would not stay up.

Let’s back up before I show you how to repair the stopper. Thank you to Dvorty Girl for the excellent illustration above that she posted on WikiHow.com.

Sink parts:
  1. Drain Down Rod
  2. Joint Clamp Clip
  3. Horizontal Rod
  4. Nut
  5. Ball, Rod, Nut & Gasket
  6. Stopper Notch
  7. Pop Up Drain Stopper

Materials:

Universal Pivot Ball Replacement Kit
Pliers (maybe)

Instructions:

1. Clear out enough room so you can work under the sink. (Okay, my mom is going to kill me for showing you her cluttered sink vanity. But, who’s sink vanity doesn’t look like this?! Please leave a comment and tell her that she’s not the only one!)

2. Lay down some towels to cushion the edge of the vanity (or your back, rib cage or hips will be in screaming pain.)

3. Locate the (3)horizontal rod and (5) nut at the back of your drain that holds the (5) ball, rod & gasket.

4.  Unscrew the (5) nut with your fingers or use pliers if it is really tight. Pull out the ball and gasket.
5. To release the (3) horizontal rod from the (1) down rod, squeeze the (2) joint clamp clip between your fingers and slide it off the end of the horizontal rod.
6. Lay out your old pieces to assess the damage. You may or may not need a new gasket (which is sold separately.) This one was broken and needed replacing.
7. Match the old pivot ball with the new ones in the kit. Be sure to choose the one that is exactly the same size. Thread the (5) new ball onto the new (3) horizontal rod.
8. Next thread the new gasket onto the horizontal rod and then the nut.
9. Next feed one end of the (2) joint clip clamp (the kit I bought contained two white stoppers instead of a joint clip clamp). Only add one side or one stopper at this point.)
10. Feed the (3) horizontal rod into the (1) down rod.
11. Line the other end of the (3) horizontal bar up and slip the ball joint into the hole at the back of the drain. Ideally the horizontal bar will be parallel to the floor, but you may have to make some minor adjustments at the end.
12. Screw the nut back onto the drain making sure the ball joint and gasket are lined up properly.
13. Now add the second stopper or the other end of the (2) joint clamp clip to the back of the (3) horizontal rod.
14. Look inside the drain, and notice the post end of the (5) ball joint inside the drain.
Pull up on the (1) down drain rod and make sure that it moves up and down freely and the post in the drain moves as well.
15. This next step requires a little patience, so put your patience cap on. Feed the drain stopper back into the drain. You want the end of the stopper to be at a 90 degree angle from the ball joint post as show below.
Gently rotate the stopper 90 degrees until the end of the stopper hooks the post.
16. Once the stopper has been properly rotated and hooked onto the ball joint post, test your sink by pulling up and own on the (1) drain down rod.
And you are done!
Pretty Handsome Guy thought it would be funny to re-arrange the letters in the sign.
And just to prove to you that my Mom can also be handy, this is a photo I found of her from the 1970′s when my parents were building my childhood home.
Next time your drain stopper is broken, I hope you will put off calling a plumber and fix it yourself!

Comments

  1. You're my hero! Thanks for this :)

    • Dianna Fox says:

      Definetley not only under the sink vanity to look that way. Don’t give it a second though. I want to meet the person who has a beautiful organized area down there and what’s the big deal anyway, not like it would ever be examened .

    • susan smiddy says:

      Thanks sooo much for the info, most helpful. I was able to fix the sink myself!

  2. Wow! I am SO impressed! We had a plumber here to fix a clog in our sink (among other things) and he took our stopper out when he did it, that was over a year ago, we still have no stopper because he told us he CAN'T get it back in. HA! Now I have proof that it CAN be done! Needless to say, that guy is NEVER coming back to our house (not just because of that, but because every room he worked in [bathroom, powder room and kitchen] he scratched, dented or plain broke something and cursed a blue streak) I envy you for being so handy, I would LOVE to be able to do these things myself or hire a WOMAN to do the job for me!

    I WILL be showing this post to my hubby!

    Have a wonderful Christmas!

  3. i love this! you are sooooo handy!!!

  4. Handy Man, Crafty Woman says:

    That is so awesome! I love that you not only fixed it, but of course stopped to take pictures so you could fully document this on your blog.

    You rock!! :-)

  5. Very cute post. Did you wrap those threads in teflon (sp?) tape?

  6. What a great daughter you are! I ALWAYS love a simple solution tutorial, especially from a woman's perspective. Way to go. :) Merry Christmas!

  7. Can you come live with me for a week!! :) Mom….you're not the only one with a messy under the sink cabinet. I bet it's all organized now…. thx to your daughter ;)

    Merry Christmas to you and your family.

  8. You are THE BEST!!! Thank you for the tutorial. I will be working on each of our sinks tomorrow!

    Always, Teresa T.

  9. Thanks this was right on time for me. I can't wait to repair this. I kept thinking why bother I have to yank that ugly sink out one day when I remodel.The truth is it will be a while before I can afford to do the whole job and in the mean time miscellaneous things keep falling down the hole. Most recently a screwdriver clogged it rather well and wasn't easy to extract. So now that I know what that kit is called I am going to pick one up. Love ya for this.

  10. Cool Breeze says:

    I so enjoyed this article immensely! The Teflon tape is not needed for screwing the plastic piece. That’s overkill. The best part is that the pivot ball assembly is made of plastic so it won’t rust anytime. I can see in your moms sink here that most other parts (water lines,etc) were replaced by nylon/plastic tubing as well. The trap is definitely original. It appears she has very hard water usage there.
    The pictures and illustrations were on the money handy girl. I loved the step by step. Even a guy can now fix this without having to read. lol

    In the end, the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree. You got your moms great brain genes. The hair clip idea was excellent and very funny.

    The finale here was the ingenious way Handsome Guy re-arranged the letters on your moms sign!
    Oops! I can see he didn’t use Teflon tape to make them stick! ;D

    -=Cool=-

  11. I can’t believe your step-by-step instructions gave me the courage to tackle this project by myself and it was so easy! Who needs a man around the house when you have the internet!!! Thank you so much for taking the out to take the pictures and for the comprehensive narration!

  12. Very helpful! Thanks for posting,

  13. What exactly is the gasket called? When my sink was taken apart it got lost and I don’t know what to replace it with !!!!!!!!

  14. This web site was perfect and totally EASY to follow. Thanks for the help!!!!!!

    God Bless and Happy Thanksgiving!!!!!!!

  15. This was the best guide I found to help me do this exact repair. The broken/deteriorated ball rod looked the same and I happened to buy the same kit. I had trouble with the tension of the pull road (i.e., the rod wouldn’t stay up), but your helpful photos helped me fix the problem. I am indeed a man, and I only care about the advice, not who gives it! The “who needs a man?” comments hurt a bit :-), but I understand the sentiment. Save the plumber’s time for the complicated stuff.

    • ST, thank you so much for your comment. Glad the tutorial helped. I hope you don’t take that comment personally, there are so many women who were brought up to believe that they couldn’t be handy or fix things because they aren’t men. They are just expressing their new found confidence ;-). BTW, I always like to hear from the handy men out there too.

  16. Mine just broke, and this information gives me the courage to try it myself! Thanks!!

  17. I need to do this, so I am bookmarking for future project. All the pictures are soooo helpful. Thanks.

  18. Diane aka Josephine says:

    I have fixed some plumbing problems in the past so my husband calls me Josephine. She was on a commercial for Draino or something years ago. Anyone remember her? So the stopper in the sink broke and we were stumped. My husband took it apart, but we were stumped. This is perfect so now Josephine can take over I guess. Love the pictures. Thanks for the detailed posting. Can’t wait to use this to get it fixed.

  19. Mary Ann McAfee says:

    Your directions were wonderful! The pictures really helped. I had to cut off the end of the rod because of some pipes at the back of my sink cabinet, but the stopper is working find now. Without your step-by-step directions I would have had to hire someone to do a relatively simple job. I am a 72 year old woman.

  20. Perfectly understandable directions and illustrations! Thank goodness I found your post after so many I found too difficult to follow. I will attempt this on Monday.

  21. dirk funk says:

    hi, thank you for such an informative piece, i got mine all fixed up! Bought a replacement kit, but small gaskets and used teflon tape to rig it up.

    Thank you for taking the time to write this and put it online with pictures and drawings.

    sean

  22. I did it! I did it! I did it!!!

    Thanks!

  23. I every time spent my half an hour to read this
    blog’s articles or reviews every day along with a mug of coffee.

  24. plumbd out says:

    Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. The pictures — awesome.

  25. This is a real handy article. Can you also please list of each item name and where I can get it?

    I am really going to try this for this weekend, wish me luck! :-))

  26. Samantha C says:

    I have been trying this repair all weekend (independently of finding your site), and I can’t figure out how to get water to stop leaking out around the ball joint. I actually rejected that universal kit because it didn’t have that little gasket and I couldn’t find them anywhere separately. I found a different kit that had a gasket in it but that one keeps leaking too. Any suggestions?

    • Samantha, you might need a whole new drain assembly. You can unscrew the drain from the collar around the stopper. And then loosen the large nut above the PVC p-trap. It’s not too difficult to replace AFTER you get the drain out. That can prove a tad tough, if it is old and has been there a while. Try googling replacing sink drain.

  27. This tutorial saved me $400+ in plumber bills. THANK YOU! great stuff.

  28. I just fixed my sink in under 15 minutes thanks to your tutorial. Thank you so much!

  29. Susan Sturtz says:

    Thank you for woman instructions and pictures. After reading and seeing, I said, “I can do that, ” and I did in about 10 minutes.

    Thank you for your simple, easy to follow instructions!

  30. Thank you. Perfect illustration! It’s much better than written instructions. I think I can do this now!

  31. I followed all the directions, and everything seems to work, except for the last step. I cannot get the stopper to hook on to the rod. I am trying to be patient but it’s not working. :( Please advise.

  32. Thanks Pretty Handy Girl. I’ve just fixed my sink pop up for less than £10. Would have been at least £45 if I’d called a plumber. Not only have I saved money, doing it myself has made me feel great! :-D

  33. Thank you, thank you, thank you! Great tutorial–photos helped tremendously! Just fixed our bathroom sink this morning thanks to you. :-) Do you have any advice on how to get the drain stopper to sit up higher to allow more water to go down? I’ve moved that rod into 3 different holes but am not getting the results I’m wanting. Thanks again–will definitely bookmark your blog!

  34. Hi, I purchased the repair kit after seeing your website. It works fine now. Other sites tell you to replace the whole drain piece, which is crazy.

  35. Marylynn Swartz says:

    I have everything apart and keep my phone with your great directions by my side. Thanks so much!!! Here is the issue. The new horizontal rod that I have attached to the new ball is a bit too long and I can’t get the darn ball back into the pipe no matter how much I twist. ( my sink cabinet is only 18″ wide. Shall I cut off a bit of the rod? Also, the gasket is almost broken and my local hardware box store doesn’t carry them. Help.

    • Marylynn,

      You’ll probably have to contact Moen to see if they can send you a new gasket. And, I’m not sure I follow the issue with the down rod correctly, but if you have to you can probably cut it short. Or would it work to attach the horizontal rod before inserting the ball into the drain?

  36. Marylynn Swartz says:

    One other thing. Now my Moen faucet leaks if I don’t leave the handle turned all the way to the right. Do I really have to replace the entire cartridge? The faucet has one handle that you lift and I don’t see how to get into the cartridge.

    • Well, you can just replace the rubber washer if you still like your faucet. But, you’ll still have to take it apart. Usually by the time our faucets leak they look awful (because of hard water) and I like to just replace them. but, that decision is up to you.

  37. Marylynn Swartz says:

    I brought it to work and had it cut. I need to buy a Saws All Thanks.

  38. Marylynn Swartz says:

    I just have to unscrew and remove the faucet and then the screen etc? What kind of wrench won’t scratch the chrome.

  39. Extremely easy to follow. Awesome help.

  40. Brenda Lewis says:

    Your directions are great & easy to follow! But I still have a problem with it leaking. Did you have only 1 gasket. I replaced the faucet & it came with a ball & rod, but the ball was too large. so I bought the replacement kit with correct size ball. The faucet came with 2 gaskets, 1 for each side of the ball. I don’t remember if there was a 2nd gasket on the old ball that broke.

  41. So I ended up on this page while searching for a way to *eliminate* the pop-up stopper. Basically, I want to remove everything, and cap off the actuator hole. Anybody sell a little kit for that, do you suppose? I ask, only because I had no idea there was a universal repair kit for the actuator as you’ve shown. I’ve just always kluged mine back together when I clean them out. I’m just done with the hair-catcher post actuator in there. I don’t need to ever stopper the sink, and just want to use a drop=in strainer.

    And one other note to get off my chest: Why don’t we have something better than this “technology” for our drains now? Yikes.

    Thanks for the great write-up. If I hadn’t known how to do it before, it sure would now. You’ve helped a lot of people save time, money and frustration!

    • Darell, You should check at your local hardware store and ask someone in plumbing. Okay, but here is something that you could try (although keep all your parts because it may not work. What if you cut a piece of rubber (like from an old inner tube) and fit it in the nut before screwing it back on? I’d put a basin underneath while you test it out for a while. In theory it should work…maybe?

  42. Not a bad thought. After looking at the images of your mom’s broken actuator, it may be the easiest to just nip off the post that catches the pop-up, and put the thing back together with just the ball as the sealer. I’ll figure it out. Thanks again!

  43. I use a scrap piece of leather. I find that my tools will still mar through cloth or rubber. But the leather gives good traction and is tough enough to prevent the tools from doing damage. Find an old belt or purse or shoe and cut it up!

  44. Thanks for these instructions. My stopper has been stuck for months. This handy girl (me) knew that she wanted to try fixing it herself. Will have out of town visitors this week, so I said “better now, then later”. It’s fixed!!!

  45. Thank you. It was your hand-drawn diagram that led me to this site. I’ve spent more time than I should have on this bathroom sink job, as I couldn’t get the rod into the hole in the bottom of the pop top stopper. So, I got out some thread and looped it through the hole and voila! Thank you for your detailed instructions!

  46. Thank you! I am an extremely clumsy guy, and most of DIY works I reluctantly did were unsatisfactory. This one seems to be in working order thanks to your detailed instructions.

    Your picture shows the Universal Fit Ball Rod Assembly, Dunco #88532. I think the one I got at Home Depot, Universal Lavatory Pop-Up Ball Rod, Partsmaster Pro 58423, is exactly the same thing.

    I have a question: What if I did not insert the gasket? Does that affect the longevity of this fix? The old broken system did not contain it anyway.

  47. Hi there,

    I have a somewhat weird problem. The hole that the pivot rod goes through is big causing water to leak into my cabinet. Anyway to fix this problem?

    Thanks,
    GiGi

  48. Jane Yokoyama says:

    Great instructions and drawings. Thanks to this site I was able to fix it perfectly. Our sink which we have not used for months is now ready for our guests. Please keep up the helpful repairs. You are my go to girl!

  49. Appreciated the how-to, I had exactly the same problem and I liked that you had a picture of a broken pivot rod because when I pulled mine out I wasn’t sure if it was supposed to be that way or not. Also that the name of it is ‘pivot rod’ and not ‘doohickey thing’ so I looked like I knew what I was doing when I asked the guy at the hardware store for a new one.

  50. Thanks! My fix wasn’t that complicated but just looking at the diagram made me realize I should at least take a look before dumping money on a rubber stopper. (Although I did find a cool one that looks like a fish!)

Trackbacks

  1. […] especially liked the instructions and illustrations on the Pretty Handy Girl site. I went to the hardware store, stared at the astonishing array of plumbing gadgetry, and […]

Add Comment Register



Speak Your Mind

*